Mooring Contract in Yachting Law: Marina Liability Explained
Expert legal advice on mooring contracts, yacht theft, marina liability and insurance disputes. Capece Minutolo Law Firm, specialists in yachting law.
In the world of yachting and recreational boating, the mooring contract is one of the most widely used agreements. However, it is often underestimated, despite its significant legal implications for both yacht owners and marina operators.
Although the mooring agreement is not expressly regulated under the Italian Civil Code, the Code of Navigation, or the Code of Recreational Boating, case law qualifies it as an atypical contract. Its essential structure involves the assignment of a defined water area within the marina and access to port facilities. This may also include ancillary services such as custody of the yacht, safekeeping of onboard equipment, and even winter storage (Italian Supreme Court, Joint Civil Sections, no. 8224/2007).
What Is a Mooring Contract in Yachting?
A mooring contract governs the relationship between the yacht owner and the marina operator. At its core, it concerns the right to berth a vessel in a designated space. Yet, depending on the clauses and services offered, it can also imply wider obligations relating to custody, insurance, and liability.
When Is the Marina Liable for Yacht Theft or Damage?
The central legal issue is whether the marina assumes a duty of custody over the vessel.
According to the Italian Supreme Court (Civil Section III, no. 6839/2024), if no explicit or implicit obligation of custody exists, the operator is not liable for theft of the moored yacht. However, where the marina provides security staff, CCTV surveillance, or insurance coverage, an ancillary obligation of custody may arise. In such cases, the marina must exercise due diligence under Article 1768 of the Civil Code.
In disputes, the burden of proof lies with the yacht owner who alleges liability. The Court of Ancona (judgment no. 482/2024) confirmed that liability cannot be presumed: the claimant must prove the existence of a contractual duty and its breach.
Common Disputes in Mooring Agreements
Conflicts between yacht owners and marina operators frequently involve:
• theft of the yacht;
• theft of onboard equipment or valuables;
• damage caused by storms or adverse weather;
• breakage of mooring bollards, pontoons, or port infrastructure.
Each case depends on various factors: the clarity of contractual clauses, the existence of a valid yacht insurance policy, and the conduct of both parties before and after the incident. No universal rule applies—each dispute requires an individual legal assessment.
How to Protect Your Rights under Maritime Law
In a high-value sector such as yachting law, acting promptly and strategically is essential. Signing a mooring contract without fully understanding its implications may expose both yacht owners and marina operators to significant risks.
Effective dispute management requires specialised knowledge of maritime law, insurance disputes, and international case law. Professional legal assistance can make the difference between liability and protection.
Legal Assistance in Marina Liability Cases
If you have suffered yacht theft, damage at berth, or received a claim from a marina, you should seek immediate legal advice. Our law firm provides tailored strategies to protect your interests in Italy and internationally.
If you need legal advice on mooring contracts, marina liability or yacht insurance disputes, contact us today. We assist yacht owners and operators worldwide.
Studio Legale Capece Minutolo
Avv. Gianmarco Capece Minutolo
